5 Signs Your Insurer Mishandled Your Claim


Dealing with insurance claims can already feel stressful, and it’s even worse when your insurer seems to be making things harder than they need to be. If you suspect something isn’t right, early guidance from an insurance bad faith attorney Matt Sharp can help you to understand your options. But there are some clear warning signs that your claim may have been mishandled, so you’re not going to be confused. Let’s take a look at 5 common red flags to watch out for.

Unexplained delays.

A legitimate claim should move along in a reasonable time. If your insurance company keeps checking on your claim for weeks or months without providing you answers, that’s a problem. Constant delays, especially without updates or explanations, can be assigned. The insurers trying to avoid paying or what they owe keep a record of every call, e-mail or letter. Documentation will be your best friend if things do escalate.

Lowball offers.

Sometimes insurance companies make an offer that seems way too low compared to actual losses because they’re banking on the fact that you won’t fight them.It’s common with property damage, medical expenses or car repairs. Global offers can feel insulting, but it can also be a sign that the company’s undervaluing your claim in bad faith. Don’t rush to accept it. Take the time to review the damages, get estimates, and consult an expert if necessary.

Denials with no explanation.

If your claim is denied without a clear reason, or the reason doesn’t make sense, you have a problem. Insurance companies are legally required to provide an explanation, and vague statements like not covered without details are suspicious. Your denial should come with specifics about why the policy doesn’t cover the claim, including language and supporting evidence.

Pressure to settle quickly.

If you’ve ever felt rushed to sign paperwork or accept a settlement before you’re ready, that’s another red flag.Insurers sometimes use time pressure to get you to agree to less than you deserve. Never let anyone rush you. Take your time to review your documents, get professional opinions, and make sure the settlement reflects your actual losses.

Poor communication or avoidance.

When calls are going unanswered, emails are getting ignored, or you’re constantly shuffled from one Rep to the next, that’s a warning sign. Good insurance companies communicate clearly, provide updates and answer things in a timely manner. If you feel like you’re chasing them instead of the other way round, it could indicate mishandling or intentionally bad faith behaviour.

If you notice one or more of these signs, you need to act. Document everything from emails, letters and phone calls to photos and repair or medical estimates. Everything should stay organised so you have a clear record and you should bring in the legal team. Experienced attorneys who handle insurance bad faith claims can help with reviewing your case or explaining your rights and helping you to take steps to get what you deserve. Insurance policies are meant to protect you, not make life more complicated.

We are not lawyers and this is in no way intended to be used as legal advice . We cannot be held responsible for your results. Always do your own research and seek professional legal help.


Leave a Comment